St Paul's Bentleigh
PDF Details

Newsletter QR Code

122 Jasper Road
Bentleigh VIC 3204
Subscribe: https://spbentleigh.schoolzineplus.com/subscribe

Email: office@spbentleigh.catholic.edu.au
Phone: 03 9557 7130
Fax: 

Thoughts With a Cuppa

On the 1 st July 2019 The Assisted Dying Law comes into effect in Victory. This
law raises much debate in our Community.
A dear friend of mine, Fr Geoffrey King died of MND in May of 2015. He was
a man of great Faith. He was a person of few words. But when he spoke you
listened.
As we continue to debate what this law means for us as Christians who see life
as a gift and not ours to take perhaps it is worth taking the time to read Geoff’s
article which appeared in The Age in 2013. His reflection may help us to see
things in a new way.


Edward Dooley (Mission and Faith Leader)


Life or death decision inspired by faith in God


Despite suffering motor neurone disease, I wont take my own life as Beverley
Broadbent did.By Geoffrey King (written April 2013) [Died May 7 th 2015]


I read with great interest, and I hope empathy, the story about Beverley
Broadbent ending her life. I think I can appreciate her choice to end her life
while still able to enjoy living. But it is not a choice that I intend to make.
It is, nevertheless, a choice that confronts me. I was diagnosed almost two years
ago with motor neurone disease, admittedly with a rare variant of the disease
that typically progresses more slowly than the more common forms.
Already my legs are virtually useless and I spend about 14 hours a day in an
electric wheelchair. I need help to get into and out of bed and to get to the toilet.
More recently I have noticed the beginning of weakness in my right arm - a sign
of things to come, as all of my voluntary muscles begin to shut down.
At present my determination is to live as fully as possible within these already
significant limitations. I am acting dean of the united faculty of theology within
the MCD University of Divinity. I am teaching one course within that faculty.
As a Catholic priest I celebrate Mass several mornings a week in the church at
Richmond where I live, and on Sundays at Werribee. I go to the MCG when
Collingwood is playing. I go to concerts in the city, and to exhibitions at the
NGV. I frequent cafes that serve good coffee. I do most of the food shopping
for my small community.

For some of this I need to use a maxi taxi. But more commonly I travel simply
by wheelchair or by train, courtesy of a free myki pass and the help of train
drivers who put out a ramp for me. When my arms and upper body become
weaker, all this will be more difficult, ultimately impossible, but I have
managed thus far to adapt in ways that would a few years ago have seemed
improbable to me, and I hope such adaptation can continue.
Why, however, do I choose to press on into the more horrendous parts of this
motor neurone journey, rather than seeking to take Beverley Broadbent's path?
Ultimately for me this is not a matter of reason, but a matter of faith. I believe in
a creator (and creative) God and I believe in the paradoxical power of the cross.
For me, life is a gift from God. So far it has been an extraordinarily generous
gift. I have been able to do things, and to experience things, and to go to places
(places of the heart as well as geographical places) that I would never have
conceived of when I was, say, 20. I have had a wonderful life, and for this I am
immensely grateful. I have now entered into much darker places, but even here I
find new life: there is a sense of adventure, for example, in finding how to do
even simple things from the constraints of an electric wheelchair.
I know that I shall never again go for 40-kilometre walks along Washington's
C&O Canal, nor wander around the Parthenon on a misty morning, nor drink a
dark lager in Munich's Augustiner Bierhalle, nor go to an outdoor concert at
night in the Roman Forum, nor even catch a ferry on Sydney Harbour. There is
deep regret in all of that, but it is far outweighed by a sense of gratitude that I
have been able to do these things in the first place.
And then there is the cross. I do not believe that suffering is meaningless, but
that, like Christ's suffering, it can be redemptive. Of course, we should do all we
reasonably can to prevent suffering, but we will still be confronted with it.
This awful disease puts me in solidarity with others suffering around the world.
It has enabled me to enter into the world of the disabled, such as the other
wheelchair passengers I meet on the train. With them I see the world with new
eyes. And in small ways I have become an advocate for the disabled and for
disability access. I have been inspired by the peacefulness of other motor
neurone sufferers, some of them much more disabled than I am.
I have also discovered how much people love me. Prayers, good wishes, and
material help have come from places expected and quite unexpected. Through
my blog (geoffreysj.com), I have met new friends and reconnected with old
ones. Having motor neurone disease, then, has enabled me to live life in new

ways. I actually see it as a gift, a very challenging and mysterious gift, from a
life-giving God.
None of this is to pretend that motor neurone is not an absolutely awful disease,
that the later stages in particular are about as nasty as it gets. As a friend
remarked, getting motor neurone disease is drawing the shortest of short straws.
I just hope that I can maintain my positive attitude as things get a lot tougher.
Nor do I want my life to be artificially prolonged, by being kept going on a
ventilator, for instance, as my breathing muscles fail. At that point I want to be
allowed to die, but for me that is very different from taking positive steps to end
my life.
None of this is meant as a direct comment on the politics of euthanasia, nor is it
an attempt to rebut the views of Beverley Broadbent. My attitude is based on
my Christian faith. I do not want to impose my views on those who do not share
that faith. But it is the statement of someone who wants to live life to the full,
who has found some of that fullness in the unlikeliest of places, and who trusts
the amazing grace that has brought me safe thus far to lead me on.
Geoffrey King is a Jesuit priest and acting dean of the united faculty of
theology, a college of the MCD University of Divinity (originally known as
the Melbourne College of Divinity).
For an article arguing other viewpoints on this issue you might like to read:


We must not deny the sick a dignified death